The
most hyped and high profile hunger strike of Baba Ramdev has shaken the
country's veteran politicians. In fact it forced the administration to initiate
police action (in the middle of the night on 4th June, 2011) to tamper the
entire movement and send Baba to his home in Haridwar.
For last two years, the government linked financial scandals have become a
regular news feature. The media is making the best use of each of the story to
increase their net worth. International agencies are rating India as the best
and most corrupt business destination in the whole world. India is now better
recognised as land of financial scandals, bribery, scams etc. Probably, this is
one of the most defining reason for foreign companies to do business in India.
The rampant corruption is supplementary incentive to every foreign company doing
business in India.
Since independence, the country has seen unparallel inflation, growing
unemployment, shortages of essentials, falling real income, deteriorating law
and order situations, mismanagement at International frontiers etc.
Unfortunately, these negativities generate wealth for handful persons at the
cost of the masses.
People like Anna Hazare and Baba Ramdev think that the, situation can be
improved in the interest of common person. They get emotionally attached to the
cause and the country. They feel they can be the instrument of change. They
dream to improve the plight of the common person. They take their mission to the
people. Unfortunately, they don't know the system, they don't understand the
politics, they don't have the organisation, they don't have the professional
experience. They live in the world of dreams.
The
problem of Indian money parked in foreign bank accounts is nothing new. As it
appears, the government is already working on this issue. But bilateral
relations, international treaties and customs are restraining the executives to
increase the pace of their efforts. We hope, after Baba Ramdev's episode, the
government will augment
its efforts in
this direction. The other issues raised by Baba Ramdev regarding corruption,
education etc. are extremely relevant and we again hope the government will show
sincerity and honesty to tackle these issues under time bound programme.
In
any case, the police action of the government at Ramleela Ground, New Delhi can
not be accepted in any civilized world. A strong number of about 5,000 police
men entered the campus little after midnight, where more than 60,000 devotees
including women and children were sleeping. Police used tear gas shells to
create panic in the small place. The light were switched off. Who so ever tried
to intervene or argue was physically thrashed. Confirmed injury figures are not
available. Many are still untraceable. We can not find any other example of this
event in the history of India. We deeply condemn the approach of the
administration in handling this issue.
We
wish good for Baba's mission and also wish him good health and long life. Since,
the Supreme Court is now dealing with the subject, we hope appropriate relief
will be granted to all who have suffered. We also hope the government will
henceforth become more transparent and affective in handling various issues
raised by Baba Ramdev and Anna Hazare.
We
have a suggestion for both Government of India and Baba Ramdev about the problem
of Indian Black Money, stored in Swiss Banks etc. If the Scheme suggested herein
below can be applied through the Government Ordinance, the problem can be
resolved in the best interest of India..
The
scheme can be named, “INFRASTRUCTURE FUNDING THROUGH FOREIGN REMITTANCES
SCHEME- 2011”.
This
scheme may be based on the following guidelines. The scheme primarily offers
foreign account holders to repatriate funds back to India with immunity from
prosecution. All the incoming remittances under the scheme can be taxed
reasonably (say 15%). Besides, the Government can also put certain conditions to
route these remittances for the development of Indian infrastructure sector e.g.
education, health, transport, energy, communication, road development etc. The
scheme should be kept open for at least three years so that, effective results
can be achieved. It takes time to understand the scheme and generate the
required confidence in the law.
The
adoption of this scheme can bring unprecedented success in bringing Indian
precious foreign exchange back to country. This is the sole objective of Baba
Ramdev. If we want practical solutions, the issue of handling corruption should
be addressed separately. For this purpose the government is already in agreement
with Baba Ramdev. Special Courts in adequate number can be setup both at central
and state level to enforce discipline in the administration of the country. We
hope the government will act in the right direction and Baba Ramdev will also
accept practical solutions in the overall national interest.
INFRASTRUCTURE FUNDING THROUGH FOREIGN REMITTANCES SCHEME- 2011
Salient
Features
1. All
individuals and companies will be permitted to receive foreign remittances
through recognized banking channels without declaring the source of funds. Cash
deposits can also be accepted.
2. The
remittance receiver will only be required to provide a declaration that,
receipts do not relate to drug, terrorism and arms dealings.
3. All
remittances under this scheme will be termed “Foreign Receipts” herein after
referred as “FRs”.
4. The
scheme should remain open for thirty six months after notification.
5. All
FRs should be deposited first in a bank account opened for this specific purpose
only ( like FCRA Scheme). Only one bank should be entrusted to provide banking
facilities under this scheme. This will help the Government in monitoring the
inflow and collecting taxes etc. State Bank of India is ideally suited for this
purpose as they have country wide network.
6. All
FRs should be invested with in nine months in the Central Government approved
infrastructure projects. i.e. projects in the field of education, health
services, transport, communication, energy etc. All infrastructure projects
should be located in a town / village having population of less than 10 lakhs.
Highway projects may be exempted from this requirement.
7.
Receipts can also be invested in infrastructure development through the
subscription of Infrastructure Bonds issue by Government. The bonds to be issued
should have a lock in period of 5 years. The bonds may carry interest of 3.5%
p.a. payable half yearly.
8. All
FRs under this scheme should be taxed at the flat rate of 12.5%. This tax should
be collected by the receiving bank same as TDS.
9.
Recipients of FRs should be provided total immunity from prosecution and
penalties for the amount received by them under this scheme.
10. All
FRs under this scheme should be received in convertible / acceptable foreign
currency.
Effects
of this Scheme on Indian Economy
1. Under
this simple scheme, we can expect an inflow of massive amount of foreign
remittances.
2. Since,
the inflow of foreign exchange will be on non repatriation basis, Government can
use it to repay its expensive foreign loans and make the country debt free for
the first time since independence. We will save crores of rupees which are
presently paid as interest on foreign loans.
3. Indian
currency will instantly get stronger and may even beat the lead currencies of
developed nations.
4.
Foreign exchange reserves will increase substantially.
5. RBI
can become a net lender instead of habitual borrower.
6. All
kinds of unemployment will vanish as physical development will take place in
small towns and villages across the country.
7.
Consumption of steel, cement, labour and other inputs in developmental projects
will multiply national income. Both direct and indirect revenue will increase
many many folds.
8. The
scheme will completely transform the country with in thirty six months unless
blocked by vested interests in and outside the country.
9.
Average literacy rate in the country may go as high as 95% to 98% due to
additional educational institution promoted under this scheme.
10.
Health services will become much more economical and accessible by common
person.
Precautions and Measures Required for the Success of the Scheme
1. The
scheme will need wide publicity around the world.
2. Indian
embassies should be involved to project the scheme.
3. Help
centers and guidance centers should be set up to explain the scheme.
4.
Immunity from prosecution to all recipients and their associates should be given
in unambiguous terms.
5.
Question regarding sources of funds should not be requested. This will defeat
the basic objective of the scheme.
6. The
use of terms like black money etc. should be avoided as that will be counter
productive. The amount parked outside India for various reasons can be referred
as “Foreign Investments”. This will generate tremendous goodwill.
7. The
scheme should be managed / administered by independent committee reporting
directly to Planning Commission. All ministerial interferences should be
curtailed.
8.
Infrastructure projects should be identified by planning commission, keeping in
mind five year plans. These projects should be auctioned in open house on
regular intervals to the individuals and companies participating in this scheme.
9. All
surplus funds should be invested through Reserve Bank of India on commercial
terms so as earn at least 8% to 10% returns p.a.
10.
Religious donations should be kept out of this scheme. Scheme should not
encourage flow of religion base funds.
11.
Government should have the law to reward handsomely and quickly the informers
about storage of illegal money.
12. The
foreign account holders who fail to close their unauthorised accounts with in
thirty six months (during the period of scheme) should be severely penalized and
punished. Scheme can provide for minimum imprisonment of ten years for holding
unauthorized accounts along with fine equal to amount deposited. No exceptions
and no exemptions from the penalties should be provided. Informers of
unauthorized accounts should be generously rewarded by cash incentives.
Conclusion
This
scheme, if implemented with supporting awareness programme may change the face
of the country in short span of three years. Issues relating to corruption etc.
can be resolved discreetly. Government Treasury will start over flowing. Indian
Economy can achieve 0% unemployment and net lender certificate from the World
Bank and IMF. What else we can expect in a short span of time ……………………As a
author of this scheme, I can say with confidence that, this will bring both
economic and social revolution in the country.
Request
to all the Readers of this Mail
In case
you approve and appreciate the ideas placed herein above please help the nation
by circulating this mail to all your friends, associates and all others, so that
the issues raised by Baba Ramdev can be resolved in positive atmosphere.
Click Here To Print
this Article
Tapuriah Jain &
Associates
Chartered Accountants
21,. Skipper House, 9, Pusa
Road, New Delhi - 110 005
Tele : 91-11-28754012 &
13, Mobile : 91-98-100-46108, E-Mail :
caindia@hotmail.com